Gamete donor anonymity and limits on numbers of offspring: the views of three stakeholders
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper discusses the attitudes of three groups of stakeholders in the world of assisted reproduction gamete donors, parents who use donated gamete, and offspring conceived with donated gametes with respect to the two issues of donor anonymity and limits on the number of offspring a single donor can produce. The data are drawn from on-line surveys which were made available between May 12, 2104 and August 15, 2014 to gamete donors, donor-conceived offspring, and parents who used donated gametes to conceive. A total of 325 donors (176 egg donors; 149 sperm donors) responded to the survey as did 2134 parents and 419 offspring. The data show that offspring are more opposed to donor anonymity than are parents and donors. Among offspring opposition to anonymity grows as they age. On the other hand, parents are most in favor of limits on numbers of offspring produced by a single donor. Parents worry about health and accidental contact between people conceived from the same donor.
منابع مشابه
Third-party reproductive practices: legislative inertia and the need for nuanced empirical data
INTRODUCTION In their article, ‘Gamete donor anonymity and limits on numbers of offspring: the views of three stakeholders’, Margaret K. Nelson, Rosanna Hertz and Wendy Kramer draw on survey data from gamete donors, parents who used gametes to conceive, and donor-conceived offspring in order to understand the position that various stakeholders are likely to hold regarding the regulation of two ...
متن کاملI-14: The Impact of Disclosure Decisions on Donor Gamete Participants: Donors, Intended Parents and Offspring
To discuss the psychological impact of disclosure decisions on donor gamete participants including gamete donors, intended parents, and the children conceived through these third party reproductive techniques. In the past decade, there has been a dramatic increase worldwide in the number of children born as a result of gamete donation. The growing demand for these programs has resulted in a tre...
متن کاملAs anonymity disappears the focus becomes limits on donor offspring
The five commentators who responded to our article, ‘Gamete donor anonymity and limits on numbers of offspring: the views of three stakeholders’,1 raised several of the same issues; they also expressed some quite different concerns. We thank the readers for these varied and thoughtful readings. In our brief response, we outline our major findings. We then respond first to the shared points and ...
متن کاملUniversalizing anonymity anxiety
The empirical study byMargaretNelson, RosannaHertz, andWendyKramer on stakeholder attitudes toward gamete donor anonymity and limits on gamete donation, ‘Gamete Donor Anonymity and Limits on Numbers of Offspring: The Views of Three Stakeholders’ (hereafter Gamete Donor Anonymity),1 is commendably particular on one level yet noticeably vague on another. It approaches the anonymity issue2 at a le...
متن کاملDrinking from the Data Well: Response to Gamete donor anonymity and limits on numbers of offspring: the views of three stakeholders
Data matters. Senator Cory Booker’s mantra is ‘in God we trust . . . Everybody else, bring me data’,1 and the federal government’s less catchy term for data-driven law and policy is ‘evidence-based practices’.2 Yet the privatization of familymaking generally— coital and technological—has translated to lack of government record-keeping, leaving scholars, journalists, courts, legislators, and adv...
متن کامل